Those of you who tailed our prop bets know we love Eddie P. The 2018 UDFA was a godsend for the San Francisco 49ers after being picked up from free agency after Jake Moody failed to live up to his draft stock. His first season with the team was an absolute banger: 28-of-29 on FGs, including making his first 25 in a row, and 6-of-6 from 50-59 yards. The only FG he missed was from 60+. Additionally, he hit all three playoff attempts. His performance earned him a four-year contract extension.
The success was nothing new for Eddie, which is why he earned the #10 spot on our list. The SF K1 is currently second all-time in career FG percentage (89.7%), behind only Cameron Dicker. Should he pick up where he left off in ‘25, there’s a chance he takes the lead this year. That type of reliability is invaluable for a team that makes as many red-zone trips as SF does. Being able to consistently come away with points anytime you crack the 40 is a cheat code. To illustrate his value succinctly, please take a moment to recall what it felt like seeing former K Jake Moody take the field in a key moment. No further comments needed; that dude took years off my life.
Eddie may be #10 on our list, but he’s #1 in our hearts. Being a placekicker, there’s only so high we could rank him. Still, we implore you to take notice as the season progresses of just how great it feels to watch steady Eddie ping ‘em as he never lets the moment get too big. That first over 1.5 FG prop is going to hit like Fred Warner come September, cannot freakin’ wait.